Concept2 vs WaterRower: Which Rowing Machine Is Best?
We compare the Concept2 Model D and WaterRower Natural head-to-head on resistance, noise, comfort, data tracking, and value to help you choose the right rower for your home gym.
Unbiased Advice & Insights is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks.
Concept2 Model D
Industry standard air rower with proven durability, precise performance monitor, and adjustable damper. Best for serious athletes and data-driven training.
Check priceWaterRower Natural
Elegant water rower with smooth, natural resistance and whisper-quiet operation. Ideal for home users who value design and a meditative rowing experience.
Check priceChoose the Concept2 Model D if you prioritize performance tracking, adjustability, and a proven track record in gyms. Pick the WaterRower Natural if you want a quiet, beautiful machine that mimics on-water rowing and blends into your home decor.
Spec by spec
Highlighted cell wins that row.
| Concept2 Model D | WaterRower Natural | |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance Type | Air (fan with adjustable damper) | Water (paddles in tank) |
| Noise Level | Moderate (whoosh sound) | Very quiet (gentle water swoosh) |
| Monitor / Data Tracking | PM5 with advanced metrics, Bluetooth, and memory | S4 with basic data, optional Bluetooth upgrade |
| Seat Comfort | Firm, contoured seat on monorail | Wider, cushioned seat on dual rail |
| Build Quality & Warranty | Steel frame, 5-year frame / 2-year parts | Solid ash wood frame, 3-year frame / 1-year parts |
| Storage | Upright storage kit optional, splits into two pieces | Upright storage included, splits into two pieces |
| Overall Value | Best for performance and durability | Best for aesthetics and quiet operation |
Who should buy which
- + Competitive rowers or athletes who need precise data and interval training
- + Home gym owners who want a machine that will last for years with heavy use
- + Users who don't mind moderate noise and prefer adjustable air resistance
- + Home users who value a quiet workout that won't disturb others
- + Fitness enthusiasts who enjoy the natural feel and sound of water
- + People who want an attractive piece of furniture that doubles as exercise equipment
Quick questions
Which rowing machine is quieter, Concept2 or WaterRower?
The WaterRower Natural is significantly quieter. Its water resistance produces a gentle swooshing sound, while the Concept2's air fan creates a whoosh that can be heard throughout a room. If noise is a concern, the WaterRower is the better choice.
Can I connect both machines to fitness apps like Zwift or Peloton?
The Concept2 Model D's PM5 monitor has built-in Bluetooth and ANT+ connectivity, allowing easy pairing with apps like Zwift, ErgData, and Peloton. The WaterRower Natural's standard S4 monitor does not have wireless connectivity, but you can purchase a separate Bluetooth module (ComModule) to enable app integration.
Which rowing machine provides a better full-body workout?
Both machines engage the same muscle groups: legs, core, back, and arms. The Concept2's air resistance can be made more challenging by increasing the damper setting, while the WaterRower's resistance increases naturally with stroke rate. For high-intensity interval training, the Concept2 offers more precise control over resistance and pace.